Who are the best candidates for oral appliance therapy (OAT) for the treatment of snoring and apnea? And Contraindications?
Sleep medicine providers often ask this important question: “Who are the best candidates to refer for oral appliance therapy(OAT), and what are the situations that would contraindicate a referral for an oral appliance(OA)?”
Oral appliance therapy remains one of the primary treatment options for snoring and obstructive sleep apnea. Each year, more people are becoming aware that they have a choice in treatment, especially in mild to moderate OSA cases, and even in some severe cases.
In this article, we will review who are the best candidates for OAT, and what are some of the contraindications that would promote consideration for treatment options other than OAT. The information below pertains to mandibular advancement splints(MAS), the more researched and prescribed type of oral sleep appliance.
For a list of the other pertinent questions asked by medical providers to broaden their understanding and knowledge of oral appliance therapy, see: Most Common Oral Appliance Questions Asked by Sleep Medicine Providers
Before we dive into the questions above, let’s explore current research regarding how effective oral appliances are in comparison to positive airway pressure treatment (PAP).
CPAP is more effective, but oral appliances are often accepted more and worn for longer periods potentially leading to the same overall health outcome.
On the effectiveness of oral appliance therapy as compared to PAP, increasingly, more research papers are accepting a broader scope of success than limiting to AHI levels.
- “Emergent health outcome data suggest that equivalent apnoea–hypopnea index reduction may not be necessary to produce the same health benefits of PAP. This may be related to the more favorable adherence to OA therapy, which can now be objectively verified.” (Oral Appliance Therapy for Obstructive Sleep Apnoea: State of the Art 2019 Journal of Clinical Medicine)
- “Oral appliances are the main alternative to PAP for the treatment of OSA. There has been an expansion of the research evidence supporting the use of oral appliances in clinical practice, and key professional bodies now recommend oral appliances for use in patients with OSA who are intolerant to PAP therapy or prefer an alternative therapy. Patient preference is a key component of patient-centered care and has a pivotal role in treatment acceptance, usage, and health outcomes. …” (Oral Appliance Therapy for Obstructive Sleep Apnoea: State of the Art 2019 Journal of Clinical Medicine)

Info sheet from the Thoracic Society: Oral Appliances for Sleep Apnea in Adults is a very good patient resource:
- Oral appliances are more likely to work if you have mild or moderate sleep apnea; more recent evidence supports use for some people with severe sleep apnea as well.
- The info sheet clearly states OAT is best for mild-moderate OSA but also states: “Oral appliances are more likely to work if you have mild or moderate sleep apnea; more recent evidence supports use for some people with severe sleep apnea as well.”
From a general oral appliance treatment medical perspective:
The following sources offer good science and clinical-based perspectives on this question.
- Joint Statement from the AASM (American Academy of Sleep Medicine) and AADSM (American Academy of Dental Sleep Medicine)
- Clinical Practice Guidelines for the Treatment of Obstructive Sleep Apnea and Snoring with Oral Appliance Therapy: An Update for 2015
The American Academy of Sleep Medicine (AASM) sets the clinical standards for the fields of sleep medicine health care, education, and research by publishing clinical practice guidelines, quality measures, and position statements and papers.
Here are some of the key points for whom oral appliances are indicated based on the sources above:
- Adult patients who request treatment for primary snoring (without obstructive sleep apnea).
- Adult patients with obstructive sleep apnea who are intolerant of CPAP therapy or prefer alternate therapy.
- Adult CPAP compliant patients who are interested in alternative treatment
As medical providers working with individuals, it would be prudent to listen to the concerns of the patient when choosing the best treatment option.
Please do not discount severe patients as a potential candidate for oral appliance therapy. Oral appliances can improve the quality of life of many severe OSA patients as well.
Oral appliance providers who have been in the field long enough would add that they have witnessed a considerable amount of positive outcomes in some severe cases. And on the other hand, they also have had a significant amount of failed cases in mild cases.
From a dental perspective: (best to be evaluated by the dental sleep provider)
- Adequate number of teeth to support the device
- Healthy/ well maintained periodontally
- No limitation in jaw opening
- 6mm or more of protrusive advancement capability
From a lifestyle perspective:
Many individuals could benefit from both an oral appliance and CPAP. Patients would benefit from knowing that their choice does not have to be black or white and that they may benefit from both depending on lifestyle demands/ preferences.
Here are some examples other than non-compliance when a CPAP patient may benefit from an oral appliance even if “100% compliant”.
- Patient removed the CPAP after 4 hours of use to meet the criteria
- Patient that is not wearing any treatment for the 3/10 days not needed to show compliance
- Any level struggling and feeling discouraged
- Residual OSA symptoms
- Traveling, especially shorter period of travel
- Camping to remote areas
- Mission work group trips
- “I’d rather wear an oral device when my grandkids stay over.”
- Long plane flights
- Group trips
- Boaters
- Patient wanting a discreet option
Contraindications for oral appliances (mandibular advancement splints) include a patient having…
Dental/oral related:
- Insufficient teeth to support an oral appliance
- Active periodontal issues or dental caries needing treatment
- Substantial temporomandibular joint (TMJ) disorder symptoms usually manifest in moderate active jaw pain and possible limitation of jaw opening
- Less than 6 mm jaw protrusion
- Having compromised dental restorative work / extensive amount of dental work
- Edentulous patients should seek consultation with a dentist knowledgeable in dental sleep medicine, prosthodontics, and implant restorative work
- ***Not been evaluated by a general dentist within the past year (This may delay OAT)
Other:
- Central apnea (not mixed)
- Extremely and morbidly obese patients unless combination therapy
- Reluctant to sleeping with anything in their mouth
- Extreme gag reflex/ mild cases can work through the desensitization process
It’s important to note that excluding the central apnea point above, the other situations are best evaluated by the sleep disorders dentist.
On general dental care:
***When referring a patient for oral appliance therapy, the patient should be urged to reconnect with their general dentist for a dental-oral evaluation if it’s been a while, or to have dental work in progress completed.
If these points are not addressed until their initial dental sleep provider visit, the patient should be made aware that oral appliance therapy may be delayed.
Resources
- Oral Appliance Treatment for Obstructive Sleep Apnea: An Update – Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine -Published Online: February 15, 2014
- Efficacy versus Effectiveness in the Treatment of Obstructive Sleep Apnea: CPAP and Oral Appliances (Sutherland, Phillips & Cistulli, 2015)
- Clinical practice guideline for the treatment of obstructive sleep apnea and snoring with oral appliance therapy: an update for 2015 Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine
- Oral Appliance Therapy for Obstructive Sleep Apnoea: State of the Art – Journal of Clinical Medicine 2019
- Joint Statement from the AASM (American Academy of Sleep Medicine) and AADSM (American Academy of Dental Sleep Medicine)
- Oral Appliances for Sleep Apnea in Adults American Thoracic Society patient info sheet
- Current Practice Guidelines AADSM 2022
- ****Comparative outcomes in obstructive sleep apnea therapy: mean disease alleviation as a more appropriate measure—it’s about time SLEEP 2023
This article is general in nature and for educational purposes only. Please consult with your sleep health provider before starting any treatment option for snoring and apnea.

